Janathar

Level 115, Shaman

Halo Guardians

Character

Race: Barbarian

Class: Shaman

Guild

Gender: Male

Level: 115

DKP Information

Show the points information for this Char only

Point account name	Earned	Spent	Adjustment	Events: Current	Raids (30 days)	Raids (60 days)	Raids (90 days)	Raids (lifetime)
DKP	4097.00	3817.00	-183.00	97.00	77% (41/53)	79% (85/108)	85% (134/158)	87% (3873/4453)
... 1 entries found

Raids
Items
Adjustments
Raid attendance
Notes

Raid Attendance History

Date	Name	Note	Value
03,12.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
03,12.24	On Time		1.00
03,11.24	Final Attend		1.00
03,11.24	LS - Shadow of My Shadow		1.00
03,11.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
03,11.24	On Time		1.00
03,07.24	Final Attend		1.00
03,07.24	LS - Shadow of My Shadow		1.00
03,05.24	On Time		1.00
03,04.24	Final Attend		1.00
03,04.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
03,04.24	LS - Prisoners of Ankexfen Keep		1.00
03,04.24	On Time		1.00
02,29.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,29.24	LS - Prisoners of Ankexfen Keep	first look	1.00
02,29.24	On Time		1.00
02,27.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,27.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
02,27.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
02,27.24	On Time		1.00
02,26.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,26.24	LS - What is this for?		1.00
02,26.24	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	FIRST WIN	10.00
02,26.24	On Time		1.00
02,22.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,22.24	LS - Shadow of My Shadow		1.00
02,22.24	LS - Shadow of My Shadow		1.00
02,22.24	On Time		1.00
02,20.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,20.24	LS - Shadow of My Shadow		1.00
02,20.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
02,20.24	On Time		1.00
02,19.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,19.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
02,19.24	LS - What is this for?	FIRST WIN	10.00
02,19.24	On Time		1.00
02,15.24	Final Attend		2.00
02,15.24	ToV Dagarn the Destroyer		1.00
02,15.24	NoS The Shadows Move		1.00
02,15.24	On Time		1.00
02,13.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,13.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
02,13.24	On Time		1.00
02,12.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,12.24	TimeStamp		1.00
02,12.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
02,12.24	On Time		1.00
02,08.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,08.24	TimeStamp		1.00
02,06.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,06.24	TimeStamp		1.00
02,06.24	On Time		1.00
02,05.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,05.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
02,05.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
02,05.24	On Time		1.00
02,01.24	Final Attend		1.00
02,01.24	On Time		1.00
01,30.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,30.24	TimeStamp		1.00
01,30.24	On Time		1.00
01,29.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,29.24	NoS Pit Fight		1.00
01,29.24	On Time		1.00
01,25.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,25.24	NoS The Artist	First Win	10.00
01,25.24	TimeStamp		1.00
01,25.24	On Time		1.00
01,23.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,23.24	NoS Myconid Mutiny		1.00
01,23.24	NoS Under Siege		1.00
01,23.24	On Time		1.00
01,22.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,22.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
01,22.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
01,22.24	On Time		1.00
01,19.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,18.24	NoS The Spirit Fades		1.00
01,18.24	On Time		1.00
01,16.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,16.24	TimeStamp		1.00
01,16.24	On Time		1.00
01,15.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,15.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand		1.00
01,15.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer		1.00
01,15.24	On Time		1.00
01,11.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,11.24	NoS Under Siege	First Win	1.00
01,11.24	TimeStamp		1.00
01,11.24	On Time		1.00
01,09.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,09.24	TimeStamp		1.00
01,09.24	On Time		1.00
01,08.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,08.24	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	First Win	10.00
01,08.24	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	First Win	10.00
01,08.24	On Time		1.00
01,04.24	Final Attend		1.00
01,04.24	TimeStamp		1.00
01,04.24	NoS Myconid Mutiny		1.00
... 3873 entries found / 100 are shown

Item Purchase History

Date	Buyer	Name	Raid	Itempool	Value
10,10.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	0.00
08,01.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral Luminosity Wrist Armor	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	1.00
10,17.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	0.00
11,21.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	0.00
09,05.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Pit Fight	default	0.00
09,05.23	Janathar	Baton of Jharin Revelry	NoS Pit Fight	default	8.00
07,24.23	Janathar	Ball of Krystal	NoS Pit Fight	default	17.00
02,27.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
11,09.23	Janathar	Apparitional Hand Armor Lining	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	1.00
10,09.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
11,09.23	Janathar	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
10,31.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
10,24.23	Janathar	K'kth'kik's Chew Toy	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	11.00
11,27.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
05,01.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
06,06.23	Janathar	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
03,20.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
06,26.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral Luminosity Legs Armor	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	20.00
02,20.23	Janathar	Chalice of Kerran Heraldry	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	15.00
09,14.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral Luminosity Feet Armor	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	7.00
02,06.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral Luminosity Chest Armor	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	41.00
09,14.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
07,27.23	Janathar	K'kth'tik's Chewy Tow	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	5.00
08,03.23	Janathar	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
07,11.23	Janathar	Toxiplax Claw	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	11.00
09,26.23	Janathar	Apparitional Amice Fastener	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	6.00
03,27.23	Janathar	Glowing Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
03,14.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
05,25.23	Janathar	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
05,01.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral luminosity head armor	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	37.00
09,07.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
09,07.23	Janathar	Misericorde of the Taruun	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	4.00
01,25.24	Janathar	Graffitied Stele of Deepshade	NoS The Artist	default	5.00
08,07.23	Janathar	Glowing Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
11,07.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
08,14.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
02,15.24	Janathar	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
11,07.23	Janathar	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
09,21.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral Luminosity Arms Armor	NoS The Shadows Move	default	5.00
07,25.23	Janathar	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
09,26.23	Janathar	Crys Xaui xi ans Fiel	NoS The Shadows Move	default	12.00
10,23.23	Janathar	Apparitional Leg Armor Lining	NoS The Shadows Move	default	17.00
11,13.23	Janathar	Atraeth Centien xi Vius	NoS The Shadows Move	default	8.00
08,08.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
09,14.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
06,15.23	Janathar	Virulence, Omiyad's Gift	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	4.00
09,28.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
05,09.23	Janathar	Resplendent Nature Shawl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	30.00
05,30.23	Janathar	Kajaan's Belt of Sagacity	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	51.00
09,28.23	Janathar	Apparitional Wrist Armor Lining	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	6.00
05,16.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
03,14.24	Janathar	Apparitional Essence of Power	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	2.00
10,24.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
04,10.23	Janathar	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
10,24.23	Janathar	Apparitional Arm Armor Lining	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	7.00
11,09.23	Janathar	Kejaan's Belt of Sagacity	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	4.00
01,11.24	Janathar	Apparitional Essence of Power	NoS Under Siege	default	0.00
01,11.24	Janathar	Feroocious Pernach of the Khati Sha	NoS Under Siege	default	3.00
11,13.23	Janathar	Earring of the Kai	NoS When one Door Closes	default	7.00
04,24.23	Janathar	Berserk Bludgeon of the Vah Shir	NoS When one Door Closes	default	11.00
11,13.23	Janathar	Apparitional Hand Armor Lining	NoS When one Door Closes	default	6.00
05,23.23	Janathar	Eccentric Lavalliere	NoS When one Door Closes	default	26.00
09,28.23	Janathar	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
04,24.23	Janathar	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
05,15.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
05,01.23	Janathar	Shik'Nar Carapace Crate	NoS When one Door Closes	default	17.00
11,28.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
08,08.23	Janathar	Faded Spectral Luminosity Hands Armor	NoS When one Door Closes	default	8.00
06,06.23	Janathar	Earring of the Kai	NoS When one Door Closes	default	16.00
05,30.23	Janathar	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
09,28.23	Janathar	Crippling Waistwraps of the Gate	NoS When one Door Closes	default	11.00
08,08.23	Janathar	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
07,23.14	Janathar	Rune of the Unspoken	RoF Shards Landing	default	57.00
06,29.20	Janathar	High Vizier's Cape	RoS Gorowyn	default	2.00
11,23.20	Janathar	Glowing Marked Symbol of the Ring of Scale	RoS Gorowyn	default	0.00
12,14.20	Janathar	Signet of the Forge Lord	RoS Gorowyn	default	11.00
01,05.21	Janathar	Drape of the High Arcron	RoS Gorowyn	default	2.00
12,14.20	Janathar	Flawless Conflagrant Diamond	RoS Gorowyn	default	1.00
07,07.20	Janathar	Dekloaz's Dirk	RoS Gorowyn	default	1.00
01,05.21	Janathar	Flawless Conflagrant Diamond	RoS Gorowyn	default	1.00
07,20.20	Janathar	Magma Lord's Eye	RoS Gorowyn	default	101.00
01,21.19	Janathar	Darkdream Doomhammer	Sanctum Somnium	default	0.00
09,16.13	Janathar	Median Alaran Periapt	Sarith	default	0.00
10,21.13	Janathar	Greatbow of the Waves	Sarith	default	7.00
09,23.13	Janathar	Lesser Alaran Periapt	Sarith	default	0.00
08,12.13	Janathar	Lesser Alaran Periapt	Sarith	default	0.00
09,23.13	Janathar	Minor Alaran Periapt	Sarith	default	0.00
09,03.13	Janathar	Lesser Alaran Periapt	Sarith	default	0.00
11,17.20	Janathar	Blazing Euphoria Enhancement	TBL Doomfire	default	10.00
12,01.20	Janathar	Lesser Essence of Decay	TBM Vim and Vigor	default	0.00
05,06.19	Janathar	Median Essence of Decay	TBM Vim and Vigor	default	0.00
05,21.19	Janathar	Raw Deathseeker's Wristguard	TBM Vim and Vigor	default	1.00
09,30.15	Janathar	Captured Essence of Ethernere	Tainted WK 2	default	0.00
09,30.15	Janathar	Lionskin Frock	Tainted WK 2	default	23.00
10,21.15	Janathar	Burning Steel Broadblade	Tainted West Karana	default	21.00
06,09.15	Janathar	Bracer of Suppressed Ether	Tainted West Karana	default	25.00
05,12.15	Janathar	Captured Essence of Ethernere	Tainted West Karana	default	0.00
07,08.15	Janathar	Captured Essence of Ethernere	Tainted West Karana	default	0.00
02,23.15	Janathar	Captured Essence of Ethernere	Tainted West Karana	default	0.00
07,08.15	Janathar	Eyes of the Prime Healer	Tainted West Karana	default	13.00
... 425 entries found / 100 are shown

Individual Adjustment History

Date	Reason	Value
11,29.16	RBB DKP Transfer	78.00
12,19.21	New expansion adjustment	-144.00
02,14.22	New expansion 60 day max level bonus	25.00
12,26.22	NewExpansionAdjust	-142.00
... 4 entries found

Icon	Event	Raids (lifetime)
	Queen Malarian - HARD	0.00% (0/0)
	Queen Malarian	0.00% (0/0)
	Pallarax	0.00% (0/0)
	Pallarax -Hard	0.00% (0/0)
	Crystal Core	0.00% (0/0)
	Rottrued the Twisted	0.00% (0/0)
	FoS 2	0.00% (0/0)
	Vox	0.00% (0/0)
	Black Burrow	0.00% (0/0)
	Venom Lord	0.00% (0/0)
	Venon Lord- Hard	0.00% (0/0)
	Mindblight	0.00% (0/0)
	Mind Shear	0.00% (0/0)
	Trophy Room	0.00% (0/0)
	Stasis	0.00% (0/0)
	Scrying	0.00% (0/0)
	Fippys Revenge	0.00% (0/0)
	Sacrifice	0.00% (0/0)
	Mini - Tower 5.5	0.00% (0/0)
	Generals - 6 tower	0.00% (0/0)
	Frostcrypt	0.00% (0/0)
	Lith Upper Floor	0.00% (0/0)
	Tick Tock	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Deathleaper	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Deathglider	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Bopo	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Bonecracker	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Jorth Hunter of Beast	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Maw Lurker	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Nighthowl	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Thunderpunch	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Willowcrush	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Elder Gotikan	0.00% (0/0)
	Vishimtar	0.00% (0/0)
	Demi-Performer	0.00% (0/0)
	Demi-Mayon Mistmore	0.00% (0/0)
	Ritual of Terror	0.00% (0/0)
	Grounds	0.00% (0/0)
	The Well	0.00% (0/0)
	Fos 3	0.00% (0/0)
	Epic Fights	0.00% (0/0)
	Left Guild	0.00% (0/0)
	Tov Lord Kreizenn	0.00% (0/0)
	Main Change	0.00% (0/0)
	Breeding Grounds 2	0.00% (0/0)
	Argin-Hiz	0.00% (0/0)
	Praetor Vitio	0.00% (0/0)
	RBB DKP Transfer	0.00% (0/0)
	Mercenary event	0.00% (0/0)
	Ancients	0.00% (0/0)
	Council Divided	0.00% (0/0)
	Order of Three	0.00% (0/0)
	TBM Wither and Decay	0.00% (0/0)
	TBM Damsel of Decay	0.00% (0/0)
	New Expansion adjustment	0.00% (0/0)
	Level bonus	0.00% (0/0)
	ToL Doomshade	0.00% (0/0)
	Gone year or more	0.00% (0/0)
	BOT dkp removal	0.00% (0/0)
	DKP Penalty for overspending DKP	0.00% (0/0)
	Lord Nagafen	0.00% (1/0)
	Plane of War	0.00% (3/0)
	Steel Behemoths	0.00% (1/0)
	Crushbone - HH	0.00% (1/0)
	Grelleth, Her Majesty the Queen	0.00% (3/0)
	Bixie 1	0.00% (6/0)
	Neriak 2	0.00% (12/0)
	Breeding Grounds 1	0.00% (25/0)
	Aaryonar	0.00% (2/0)
	Neriak 1	0.00% (4/0)
	Arx Mentis 2	0.00% (2/0)
	Fear	0.00% (2/0)
	Evantil	0.00% (7/0)
	New Event trial	0.00% (3/0)
	Bixie 2	0.00% (3/0)
	RoF Shards Landing	0.00% (13/0)
	Hate M	0.00% (50/0)
	LS - The Artisan and the Druid	0.00% (7/0)
	LS - What is this for?	0.00% (18/0)
	ToV Cekenar	0.00% (4/0)
	Arx Mentis 1	0.00% (8/0)
	Crystal Caverns	0.00% (34/0)
	TimeStamp	0.00% (281/0)
	Tainted West Karana	0.00% (27/0)
	ToV Sevalak	0.00% (34/0)
	On Time	0.00% (941/0)
	New Expansion Names	0.00% (5/0)
	EoK Lceanium	0.00% (5/0)
	RoF Valley of king Xorbb	0.00% (5/0)
	ToV Lady Mirenilla	0.00% (27/0)
	RoS Catcus	0.00% (6/0)
	TBL Stratus: Zephyr's Fight	0.00% (6/0)
	ToV Lord KoiDoken	0.00% (43/0)
	Dead Hills 1	0.00% (31/0)
	Sarith	0.00% (19/0)
	ToV Jorlleag	0.00% (27/0)
	EoK Chardok Prince	0.00% (15/0)
	ToL Zelnithak	0.00% (23/0)
	Final Attend	0.00% (918/0)
	NoS The Spirit Fades	0.00% (31/0)
	Dead Hills 2	0.00% (40/0)
	ToV Dagarn the Destroyer	0.00% (50/0)
	Hate's Fury (17th Anniversary)	0.00% (25/0)
	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	0.00% (25/0)
	Valley of Lunanyn	0.00% (17/0)
	NoS Shiknar Queeen	0.00% (43/0)
	NoS The Shadows Move	0.00% (18/0)
	Tower of Frozen Shadow	0.00% (10/0)
	LS - Prisoners of Ankexfen Keep	0.00% (11/0)
	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	0.00% (24/0)
	LS - Heros Are Forged	0.00% (12/0)
	RoS Gorowyn	0.00% (26/0)
	ToV Griklor the Restless	0.00% (66/0)
	CoV Zlandicar	0.00% (153/0)
	Being Patient	0.00% (14/0)
	NoS Mean Streat	0.00% (14/0)
	TBM Vim and Vigor	0.00% (45/0)
	Kael Drakkel	0.00% (40/0)
	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	0.00% (25/0)
	CoV Sontalak	0.00% (28/0)
	ToL Shei Vinitras	0.00% (85/0)
	NoS When one Door Closes	0.00% (29/0)
	EoK Temple of Droga	0.00% (32/0)
	ToV Great Divide	0.00% (49/0)
	CoV Tantor	0.00% (109/0)
	Giants Giants Giants	0.00% (1/0)
	Dragons Dragons Dragons	0.00% (4/0)
	Argath 1	0.00% (7/0)
	Lady Vox - HH	0.00% (3/0)
	Legacy Raid	0.00% (9/0)
	ToV	0.00% (6/0)
	ToV Lady Nevederia	0.00% (19/0)
	ToV Aaryonar	0.00% (4/0)
	King of Beasts	0.00% (7/0)
	Tov Lord Feshlak	0.00% (1/0)
	East Wastes	0.00% (5/0)
	Lord Nagafen - First Kill	0.00% (2/0)
	Tainted WK 2	0.00% (5/0)
	Anniversary	0.00% (7/0)
	Defense of the City	0.00% (2/0)
	Crypt of Sul	0.00% (1/0)
	Innoruuk	0.00% (2/0)
	Field of Scale	0.00% (2/0)
	Kurns Tower	0.00% (1/0)
	Under Foot	0.00% (7/0)
	Sanctum Somnium	0.00% (9/0)
	Lichen Creep	0.00% (1/0)
	Time and Tides	0.00% (1/0)
	Two Sides of the Stone	0.00% (1/0)
	Lady of Light	0.00% (3/0)
	TBM Emollious	0.00% (7/0)
	TBM Grannus	0.00% (1/0)
	Time	0.00% (1/0)
	EoK Chardok Queen	0.00% (6/0)
	EoK Labs	0.00% (1/0)
	TBL Doomfire	0.00% (1/0)
	ToV Servant of the Sleeper	0.00% (20/0)
	TBM Lady of Life	0.00% (2/0)
	Korascian Warrens: Showdown	0.00% (1/0)
	ToV Avatar of War	0.00% (22/0)
	ToV Seeking the Sorceror	0.00% (6/0)
	CoV Klandicar	0.00% (2/0)
	CoV Three Dragons	0.00% (1/0)
	ToL Aten Ha Ra	0.00% (1/0)
	ToL Netherbian Swarm Commander	0.00% (2/0)
	ToL Oubliette of Light	0.00% (11/0)
	EoK Atrebe's Vault	0.00% (1/0)
	EoK The Kar'Zok	0.00% (1/0)
	Deathknell	0.00% (1/0)
	Karnor's Castle: Mad Emperor	0.00% (2/0)
	NoS Myconid Mutiny	0.00% (20/0)
	NoS Pit Fight	0.00% (3/0)
	NoS Under Siege	0.00% (3/0)
	NoS The Artist	0.00% (1/0)
	Paineel: Inner Turmoil	0.00% (1/0)
	LS - Final Fugue	0.00% (2/0)
... 176 entries found

No notes available.

Comments

No comments available.

Halo Guardians DKP

A Drinal Based Everquest Guild

DKP Information

Raid Attendance History

Item Purchase History

Individual Adjustment History

Comments